10,000 CITIZENS CALL FOR
FOX RIVER CLEANUP
January 25, 2001
Green Bay, WI --- Over the past year, more than 10,000 signatures have
been collected on a Fox River petition, from citizens in several
communities in Northeast Wisconsin. The petition states:
"We Support Fox River Clean-Up"
"We, the undersigned, want the Fox River cleaned as quickly
as possible. The 600 pounds of PCBs which flow down the Fox River
each year must be stopped. The Fox River PCBs affect the entire
Bay of Green Bay and Lake Michigan. Scientific evidence shows
PCBs
can damage the immune system, reduce intelligence and change
behavior in children. PCBs may also cause cancer and birth
defects. We demand a strong clean-up plan that fully protects
the
health of humans and wildlife."
"Protect Our Children's Health!"
"We should be able to eat unlimited fish and duck meals with NO health
risks."
"This petition shows the public is eager for a full clean-up of the
Fox River," stated Rebecca Katers, of Green Bay, Executive Director
of Clean Water Action Council. "A partial, or slow, cleanup will
not
be acceptable."
The Wisconsin Dept. of Natural Resources and U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency are expected to propose the final comprehensive Fox
River sediment cleanup plan at the end of February. A public
comment period and hearings will follow.
"We're sending copies of these petitions to key decision-makers in
state, local and federal agencies," added Thomas Kees, of Neenah,
President of the Council. "They need to know they have public
support for an aggressive cleanup plan."
"This petition is a strong mandate for action, under both the
Superfund program and the Natural Resources Damage Assessment
program," added Curt Andersen, of Little Suamico, of the Council's
Board of Directors.
"The DNR has refused to hold public hearings about secret settlements
they've made with Fox River industries. This petition is a reminder
that the public is very interested, wants to be heard, and wants
stronger agreements than we're getting," concluded Alice McCombs, of
Shawano, Vice President of the Council
PETITION METHODS AND DETAILS:
From August, 1999 to July, 2000, our group circulated this petition
through the use of our small door-to-door canvass of staff people
who
visited residents at their homes in communities throughout Northeast
Wisconsin, from Oshkosh north to Sturgeon Bay. These
visits
included discussions of the Fox River PCB problem and proposed
options for cleanup. From this experience we know the vast
majority
of local residents strongly favor river cleanup. They also feel
the
polluters should be required to pay for the cleanup.
These petition results should not be construed to mean that
only 10,000 residents support cleanup. In fact, the
results understate total public opinion in our area, for the
following reasons:
1. Our canvass did not visit all Northeast Wisconsin communities,
only some, with special emphasis in Fox River Valley communities.
If the petitions don't include anyone from a certain town or village,
it's because we never visited it. Every community we visited
had
residents supporting the petition.
2. Our canvass could not reach all neighborhoods in the communities
we visited. If no signatures are shown on certain streets,
it's most
likely because we did not visit those streets.
3. Rural residents were not included, due to the difficulty and
high
costs of reaching dispersed homes.
4. Many people were not home on the nights we visited their
neighborhood. Sometimes 50-75% of residents were temporarily
away,
but we could not afford to go back to try again another night.
5. Some people were afraid to answer the door at night, so we
could
not talk with them.
6. Some people were busy or didn't like canvassers, so they did
not
take time to read the petition.
7. Some people were afraid to sign the petition because they thought
it obligated them to make donations, or would result in their names
being added to a phone or mail solicitation list. (Though we
assured
them this was not the case.)
8. Many people live in security-locked apartment buildings or
similar
closed neighborhoods, where we could not visit them.
9. Only one adult resident of each dwelling generally signed the
petition, because others were busy or absent. Children
were not
solicited door-to-door and rarely signed.
10. Many people who worked for the paper industry, or in other closely
related jobs, were afraid to sign the petition, because they feared
reprisal. (Though they often told us they agreed with us, appreciated
our work, and would give us anonymous donations.)
11. During the year we circulated the petition, the 7 paper companies
launched a media campaign to frighten people about the supposed
dangers of dredging. And a dredging demonstration project
(56/57)
was bungled, with heavy media exposure. This worried some residents
who otherwise supported Fox River cleanup. They were reluctant
to
sign the petition if it could result in dredging, until they could
study the issue more.
12. Our crew was small (2 to 5 people) and only part-time, visiting
neighborhoods on 2 to 4 weekday evenings each week, between the hours
of 5:30 p.m. and 9:00 p.m.
Despite these caveats, we found most residents were familiar with the
Fox River situation, and strongly supported our petition.
Of the
residents who actually read the petition, it seemed more than 90%
were willing, even eager, to sign it.
BACKGROUND ON CLEAN WATER ACTION COUNCIL:
Clean Water Action Council (CWAC) is a local non-profit citizen
organization with approximately 12,000 individual members and
contributors throughout Northeast Wisconsin. We were founded
in
1985 by local citizens when the impacts of PCB contamination on the
Fox River became more widely known. One of our primary goals
was to
clean up and prevent toxic contamination of the Fox River and other
local waterbodies.
Rebecca Leighton Katers
Clean Water Action Council of N.E. Wisconsin
1270 Main Street, Suite 120
Green Bay, WI 54302
Ph: 920-437-7304
FAX: 920-437-7326
CleanWater@cwac.net
|