

|
Environmental Deregulation
Updates:
Shoreline
Rules Drastically Weakened
Public Hearing August 3 in Green Bay
Realtors
and Legislators Manipulate Shoreline Rules Hearings
Wisconsin
Shorelines At Risk: Developers trying to block emergency rules
The Legislature is currently meeting in extraordinary session. The last
regular floorperiod ended on March 11, 2004. This was the last
general business floorperiod of the 2003-2004 legislative session. Bills
which did not pass by March 11 and which are not on the call for the extraordinary
session have died. The
Governor may still veto bills passed in the first two weeks of March. The
Legislature will not be in session again until January 2005, unless legislators
or the Governor choose to call a special session before then.
More than 18 legislative bills and an administrative
change were proposed in this last legislative session to
roll-back environmental protections.
95% of the bills' co-sponsors were Republican.
The
STATUS of each bill is included below.
What You Can Do: Read about the
bills
(below), and contact your Governor and state legislators
to tell them how you feel about these changes.
(see contact information at the bottom....)
|
|
For years, Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce (WMC), an coalition
representing some of the state's biggest polluters, and the Wisconsin
Paper Council, representing the paper industry, pushed to weaken
environmental protections.. During this recent legislative
session, they were aided by government and public fears of bad economic
news and the loss of manufacturing jobs.
"Corporate lobbyists proposed environmental deregulation to keep jobs
in Wisconsin, when these regulations are not proven to cause job loss,"
stated Katers. "In fact, several studies show the opposite: states
with a high quality of life are the most attractive for business investment."
In their campaign, industry lobbyists minimized public worries about
deregulation by calling it mere "streamlining." But the legislation
was far-reaching and a major change from past practices.
(The true cause of manufacturing job losses in Wisconsin is global competition.
Free trade rules removed equalizing tariffs which had often protected American
workers from unfair practices. Now, we are undercut trying to compete
with cheap labor in undemocratic, non-unionized countries with few worker
protection regulations. Corporations shift production to other countries,
while making "excessive environmental regulations" the scapegoat.
China is also artificially holding down their currency value, making exports
to the U.S. cheaper than they would otherwise be.)
Governor Doyle has promoted his own pro-business, pro-jobs agenda, and
his appointed DNR Secretary, Scott Hassett, also sounds like a business
lobbiest at times:
Samples of Deregulation Bills
in the Legislature
Weakening Enforcment
Our environmental health standards are meaningless without
enforcement. Currently, Wisconsin's enforcement is weak. There
is no citation or fine system for environmental violators.
Multiple violations often accumulate before the DNR considers a case worth
reporting to the Wisconsin Dept. of Justice for an enforcement action.
For example: Procter & Gamble had over 900 air pollution permit violations
before the state took action (after our legal push). Such delays
are common. In addition, the DNR generally conducts compliance checks
on permitted facilities only once or twice a year, often after advance
notice of their visit. Most emission or discharge monitoring
data is already self-monitored and self-reported by business permittees.
One priority pollutant scan (just one sample) is taken every 5 years of
wastewater from each discharger.
Job Creation Act --- This 114 page omnibus
bill covers a wide variety of regulations and would impact air and water
quality, land use, tourism, mining, solid waste, and a host of related
issues. It would gut the Public Trust Doctrine which
says that the lakes and streams of Wisconsin belong to all its citizens
and are protected in trust by the state. STATUS:
Passed by the Senate and Assembly, and signed by the Governor on January
22, 2004. See details.
-
Enforcement Immunity (SB100/AB267) --- In 2001
and 2002, industry groups worked to add what they called a "safe harbor"
provision to Wisconsin's air toxics law (NR445). In 2003, the "safe harbor"
concept was broadened and written as legislation that would create a loophole
from enforcement for all small businesses in Wisconsin. This bill would
give small businesses immunity from enforcement action as long as they
admitted to breaking the law within 45 days of the violation. This bill
is so sweeping that it would erode far more than just environmental regulations
- it will affect consumer protections, financial laws and labor laws as
well. --- Co-sponsored by 42 Republicans and 6 Democrats.
Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Welch, Roessler, Leibham, McCormick,
Krawczyk, Hundertmark, Seratti, Bies, Wieckert, Underheim, Olsen, Van Roy,
Ziegelbauer, Ott, Townsend, Owens, and Alan Lasee. STATUS:
Bills passed both houses with some amendments. Vetoed by the Governor
on Dec. 17, 2003. Senators
voting in favor: BRESKE, BROWN, COWLES,
DARLING, ELLIS, FITZGERALD, GEORGE, HARSDORF, KANAVAS, KEDZIE, LASEE,
LASSA, LAZICH, LEIBHAM, PANZER, PLALE, REYNOLDS, ROESSLER,
SCHULTZ, STEPP, WELCH, ZIEN. Assembly
members voting in favor: AINSWORTH, ALBERS,
KESTELL, SCHNEIDER, BIES, KRAWCZYK, KREIBICH, SERATTI,
FITZGERALD, FOTI, KRUSICK, LADWIG, LASEE, LEHMAN, M., LEMAHIEU,
LOEFFELHOLZ, STONE, SUDER, TOWNS, FREESE, FRISKE, GIELOW, GOTTLIEB, GRONEMUS,
GROTHMAN, GUNDERSON, GUNDRUM, LOTHIAN, MCCORMICK, MEYER,Y MOLEPSKE,
MONTGOMERY,
MUSSER, TOWNSEND, UNDERHEIM, VAN AKKEREN, VANROY, VRAKAS, HAHN,
HINES, HONADEL, HUNDERTMARK, JENSEN, JESKEWITZ, JOHNSRUD, KAUFERT,
KERKMAN, NASS, NISCHKE, OLSEN, OTT,
OWENS, PETROWSKI,
PETTIS, POWERS, RHOADES, VUKMIR, WARD, WEBER,
WIECKERT, WILLIAMS,
M., WOOD, J., WOOD, W., ZIEGELBAUER, SPEAKER.
-
Automatic Permits (SB246/AB486) --- State
agencies should be expected to thoroughly review permit applications in
order to protect health and the environment. A WMC proposal to allow
permits to be automatically issued if DNR doesn't meet their abbreviated
deadlines could lead to increased exposure to toxic chemicals or the loss
of irretrievable natural places. The proposal covers everything from water
pollution permits to construction site erosion control plans to business
mergers. At the same time, the DNR and other state agencies
are reeling from reorganizations and multiple large budget cuts over the
past 8 years, with several hundred staff lost, including many technical
permit reviewers. How can permit quality and safeguards be maintained
if the permitting is speeded up, with fewer trained people available to
do the reviews? Last spring, legislators called for a Legislative
Audit Bureau review of the DNR's air management program, which is due out
in November. The Bureau was asked to make recommendations for improving
the speed of permitting. But legislators aren't waiting for their
own analysis to be completed. The legislature already voted to support
automatic approvals. --- Co-sponsored by 32 Republicans
and no Democrats. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Leibham,
Montgomery, McCormick, Kaufert, Hundertmark, Grothman, Ainsworth, Olsen,
Owens, Welch, Roessler and Alan Lasee. STATUS:
Senate passed SB246 and sent to Assembly. AB486 was passed by the Assembly
amended. Amendment approved in Senate, now ready for scheduling.
Senators voting in favor:
BRESKE,
BROWN, COWLES, DARLING,
ELLIS, FITZGERALD, HARSDORF, KANAVAS,
KEDZIE, LASEE, LAZICH,
LEIBHAM, PANZER, PLALE, REYNOLDS,
ROESSLER,
SCHULTZ, STEPP,
WELCH, ZIEN Assembly
members voting in favor: AINSWORTH,
ALBERS,
BIES, FITZGERALD, FOTI, FREESE, FRISKE, GIELOW, GOTTLIEB,
GRONEMUS,
GROTHMAN, GUNDERSON, GUNDRUM, HAHN, HINES, HONADEL, HUEBSCH,
HUNDERTMARK,
JENSEN, JESKEWITZ, JOHNSRUD,
KAUFERT, KERKMAN, KESTELL, KRAWCZYK,
KREIBICH, LADWIG, LASEE, LEHMAN, M., LEMAHIEU, LOEFFELHOLZ, LOTHIAN,
MCCORMICK,
MEYER, MONTGOMERY, MUSSER, NASS, NISCHKE, OLSEN,
OTT, OWENS,
PETROWSKI, PETTIS, POWERS, RHOADES,
SERATTI, STEINBRINK, STONE,
SUDER, TOWNS, TOWNSEND,
UNDERHEIM, VAN AKKEREN, VAN ROY,
VRAKAS, VUKMIR, WARD, WEBER,
WIECKERT, WILLIAMS, M., WOOD,
J., WOOD, W., ZIEGELBAUER, SPEAKER.
-
Polluters Playground (SB61/AB228) --- For the
past several years, the DNR has been working to create a "Green Tier"
program that would reward industries that voluntarily reduce their impact
on the environment. During that same time, polluting industries were working
to pass legislation that would grant them special exemptions from environmental
laws. This bill is a proposal that combines both of those efforts. The
result: a bill that, if passed, would severely weaken the compliance and
enforcement of the laws protecting Wisconsin's air and water. Under this
law, industries that are regulated under Wisconsin's air and water laws
in order to protect human health and the environment would have the opportunity
to enter into contracts with the DNR. These contracts would eliminate or
severely limit the ability of the DNR to inspect the facility for illegal
pollution and grant immunity from enforcement actions if the facility does
pollute illegally. --- Co-sponsored by 19 Republicans
and no Democrats. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Montgomery,
Olsen, Ainsworth, Krawczyk, Van Roy, Ott, Bies, and Roessler. STATUS:
Passed both houses, but vetoed by the Governor on Dec. 5, 2003. Senators
voting in favor: BRESKE, BROWN, COWLES,
DARLING, ELLIS, FITZGERALD, HARSDORF, KANAVAS, KEDZIE, LASEE,
LAZICH, LEIBHAM, PANZER, PLALE, REYNOLDS, ROESSLER, SCHULTZ,
STEPP, WELCH, ZIEN Assembly members
voting in favor: AINSWORTH, ALBERS,
BIES,
FITZGERALD, FOTI, FREESE, FRISKE, GIELOW, GOTTLIEB, GRONEMUS,
GROTHMAN,
GUNDERSON, GUNDRUM, HAHN, HINES, HONADEL, HUEBSCH, HUNDERTMARK,
JENSEN, JESKEWITZ, JOHNSRUD, KAUFERT, KERKMAN, KESTELL, KRAWCZYK,
KREIBICH, LADWIG, LASEE, LEHMAN, M., LEMAHIEU, LOEFFELHOLZ, LOTHIAN,
MCCORMICK,
MEYER, MONTGOMERY, MUSSER, NASS, NISCHKE, OLSEN,
OTT, OWENS,
PETROWSKI, PETTIS, POWERS, RHOADES, SERATTI, STEINBRINK, STONE,
SUDER, TOWNS, TOWNSEND, UNDERHEIM, VAN AKKEREN, VAN ROY,
VRAKAS, VUKMIR, WARD, WEBER, WIECKERT, WILLIAMS, M., WOOD,
J., WOOD, W., ZIEGELBAUER, SPEAKER, BALOW, COLON, HEBL, KRUSICK,
SINICKI, STASKUNAS.
Water Quality Deregulation
-
Job Creation Act --- This 114 page omnibus
bill covers a wide variety of regulations and would impact air and water
quality, land use, tourism, mining, solid waste, and a host of related
issues. It would gut the Public Trust Doctrine which
says that the lakes and streams of Wisconsin belong to all its citizens
and are protected in trust by the state. STATUS:
Passed by the Senate and Assembly, and signed by the Governor on January
22, 2004. See details.
-
Navigable Waters Redefined (AB506) ---
This bill would limit or eliminate protections for many Wisconsin rivers
and streams, including: parts of the Wolf River in Langlade County, significant
portions and the tributaries of the Pine, Pike and Popple Rivers, all State
Wild Rivers, eighty-five to ninety percent of the streams in Door County,
the headwaters and significant portions of virtually all of Wisconsin's
valuable trout streams and nearly all the streams in Southeastern Wisconsin.
The definition of what waterways are "navigable" is a cornerstone for determining
protections for some of our most valuable waterways. AB506 would overturn
130 years of Wisconsin Supreme Court decisions by changing the definition
of what is a navigable stream, resulting in the removal of state water
protection for thousands of miles of some of the most valuable waterways
in Wisconsin. This change would badly weaken Wisconsin's protections against
pollution from metallic sulfide mines, such as the Crandon Mine.
(see Mining in Wisconsin)
--- Co-sponsored by 33 Republicans and 2 Democrats.
Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Ainsworth, Bies, Grothman, Hundertmark,
Krawczyk, Frank Lasee, McCormick, Olsen, Seratti, and Alan Lasee. STATUS:
Has had a hearing, but no vote in committee yet.
-
Factory Farms, Local Democracy and the Environment ---
Large-scale factory farms often lead to increased lake and river pollution,
contamination of drinking water wells, air contamination and other problems.
In Wisconsin, where we have about 115 of these facilities, local governments
can make their own land use siting decisions for factory farms. Now,
two state legislators have proposed legislation to give the state full
authority to allow farms to expand or build potentially dangerous facilities
in local communities, without the local government playing any role in
the review of the planned facility. With a decision that has the potential
to lower property values, contaminate drinking water, and force neighbors
to shut their windows due to excessive odors and flies, it is important
that the state not take away local review and decision-making over decisions
regarding the location and impacts of factory farms. (see Factory
Farms)
Air Pollution Deregulation
-
Job Creation Act --- This 114 page omnibus
bill covers a wide variety of regulations and would impact air and water
quality, land use, tourism, mining, solid waste, and a host of related
issues. It would gut the Public Trust Doctrine which
says that the lakes and streams of Wisconsin belong to all its citizens
and are protected in trust by the state. STATUS:
Passed by the Senate and Assembly, and signed by the Governor on January
22, 2004. See details.
Land Deregulation
-
Job Creation Act --- This 114 page omnibus
bill covers a wide variety of regulations and would impact air and water
quality, land use, tourism, mining, solid waste, and a host of related
issues. It would gut the Public Trust Doctrine which
says that the lakes and streams of Wisconsin belong to all its citizens
and are protected in trust by the state. Shoreline developments
are largely deregulated under this bill. STATUS:
Passed by the Senate and Assembly, and signed by the Governor on January
22, 2004. See details.
-
Eliminating Smart Growth Plans (AB435)
--- This bill would repeal Wisconsin's nationally renowned land-use planning
legislation, withdrawing state funding and support for local governments
developing local plans. (see Landuse
and Urban Sprawl) --- Co-sponsored by 15 Republicans
and 2 Democrats. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Owens, Seratti,
Ziegelbauer, Bies and Alan Lasee. STATUS:
Hearing held Oct 10, 2003, but no vote yet in Assembly Rural Affairs Committee.
-
Gutting Stewardship Funding (AB480) ---
Over the past 13 years, the Wisconsin Stewardship Fund has helped to acquire
and protect more than 225,000 acres of some of Wisconsin's most pristine
and ecologically important lands and waters. In June, 2003, the powerful
Legislative Joint Finance Committee voted to not only gut funding for the
Stewardship Fund, but also to require the state to sell off the equivalent
of 27,000 acres of currently protected land. Governor Doyle vetoed
the budget provision, but this recently proposed bill reintroduces the
cuts as legislation. --- Co-sponsored by 16 Republicans
and no Democrats. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Frank Lasee,
Seratti, Ainsworth, Van Roy and Owens. STATUS:
Referred to Assembly Natural Resources Committee on Aug 28, 2003, slightly
amended on Feb 11, 2004. Public hearing on Feb 12. Passed by
the Assembly Natural Resources Committee on a 6 to 5 vote, on March 4.
The bill was tabled (not acted on) on March 9, then again on March 10.
-
Political Games (SB252) --- Because the
Stewardship Fund is about preserving ecologically important lands, it's
important that land-buying decisions be based on science, not politics.
This bill would require the Legislative Joint Finance Committee to review
all Stewardship land purchases before the DNR can go forward with the purchase.
This procedural change would turn land acquisitions into a political decision
rather than a natural resources decision. --- Co-sponsored
by 36 Republicans and no Democrats. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors
include: Welch, Roessler, Kaufert, Gard, Ainsworth, Hundertmark, McCormick,
Olsen, Owens, Seratti and Frank Lasee. STATUS:
Passed Senate, 18 to 14, and referred to the Assembly on Nov. 20, 2003.
Passed Assembly, 58 to 37, on January 20. Vetoed by Governor on February
4, 2004. Senators
voting in favor: BROWN, COWLES,
DARLING, ELLIS, FITZGERALD, HARSDORF, KANAVAS, KEDZIE, LASEE,
LAZICH, LEIBHAM, PANZER, REYNOLDS, ROESSLER, SCHULTZ,
STEPP, WELCH, ZIEN.
-
Banning Conservation Easements (AB303)
---
This bill is another attack on land stewardship. It would ban the
state from purchasing permanent conservation easements on private land,
one of the best tools for protecting land while minimizing costs to the
state. These conservation easements are often used to protect
critical wildlife habitat, create buffer strips of filtering vegetation
along streams, or expand hunting and fishing opportunities for the public.
Buffer strips are a valuable tool for reducing non-point pollution (land
runoff); therefore, this bill hampers water quality protection efforts
in Wisconsin. --- Co-sponsored by 7 Republicans and no
Democrats. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Van Roy, Hundertmark
and Owens. STATUS: Hearing held
Aug. 6, 2003, but no vote held yet in Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
Energy Deregulation
-
New Nuclear Plants (AB555)
--- This bill would lift Wisconsin's 10 year-old ban on the construction
of new nuclear plants, costing ratepayers and taxpayers money, increasing
the risk of nuclear accidents in the state, and creating more dangerous
radioactive wastes that stay in the environment forever. Specifically,
the bill eliminates the requirement that the Public Service Commission
may not approve construction of a nuclear power plant except under two
conditions: (1) adequate U.S. disposal sites are available for radioactive
wastes; and (2) the proposed plant, in comparison with feasible alternatives,
is economically advantageous to ratepayers. This is particularly
worrisome given renewed federal government interest in locating a major
national radioactive waste disposal site in the bedrock of northern Wisconsin.
(see
Energy Efficiency
and Conservation) --- Co-sponsored by 21 Republicans
and 1 Democrat. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Frank Lasee,
Bies, Van Roy, Montgomery, Alan Lasee, Ziegelbauer, Grothman, Leibham and
Roessler. STATUS: Hearing held
Dec. 9, 2003. Recommended for passage by Assembly Committee on Energy
and Utilities, 9 to 3, on March 9.
-
Revision of Clean Air Act Implementation ---
In Spring, 2003, Governor Doyle joined 13 other states and Washington,
D.C. in suing the federal Environmental Protection Agency over rollbacks
of the New Source Review (NSR) provision of the federal Clean Air Act.
NSR ensures that power companies install modern pollution controls when
making modifications at their aging power plants. While the Governor's
decision was a good one to protect Wisconsinites health, the Governor's
own agency, the DNR, has gone on to create a committee to make revisions
to the state's NSR implementation process based on the federal rollbacks
and in conflict with the state's lawsuit. (see Air
Pollution) STATUS: Administrative revisions
are proposed. Hearings were held in January. The DNR
is pushing for final approval in May, by the DNR Natural Resources Board
and Legislature.
Non-Metallic Mining
-
Air Permit Exemption for Non-Metallic Mining(AB516)---
Exempts non-metallic mines (sand, gravel and rock quarries) from requirements
to obtain construction permits from DNR for any equipment, including a
generator or engine, at a non-metallic mineral processing facility, other
than certain crushers and grinding mills, if the person has an operation
permit for the facility. Large generators and engines can be
significant air polluters and noise problems in the neighborhood of gravel
pits and quarries. The DNR needs the authority to regulate these
activities. --- Co-sponsored by 15 Republicans and 1 Democrat.
Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Bies, Kaufert, Seratti, Olsen, Grothman
and Owens. STATUS: Hearing held
Sept. 16, 2003. Assembly passed, 63 to 32, on March 4.
Senate passed, 22 to 10, on March 11. Waiting for Governor's
signature or veto.
-
Pond Exemption for Non-Metallic Mining (AB411)---
Exempts non-metallic mines from reclamation requirements when soils are
removed for the purpose of creating a pond or wetland that has an area
of 3 acres or less. Under current law, the DNR reviews and
decides whether to approve this activity, because of potential impacts
on water quality, groundwater levels, wildlife, etc. --- Co-sponsored
by 12 Republicans and 1 Democrat. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include:
Ainsworth, Grothman, Owens, Alan Lasee and Welch. STATUS:
Hearing held July 9, 2003. Passed Assembly, 61 to 35, on March
2. Passed Senate, 21 to 12, March 4. Waiting for
Governor's signature or veto.
Tourism and Quality of Life
-
Lifting Billboard Restrictions (SB239/AB496) ---
This bill would allow repair or maintenance of non-conforming billboards
amounting to 50% of the value of the billboards in any 12-month period.
This means a billboard can be 50% repaired in one year and 50% in the next,
making it like new within two years. Non-conforming billboards are
those existing on farmland and rural (scenic) lands that would not be allowed
under current law, which was enacted March 18, 1972 following federal guidelines.
They were supposed to be removed within 5 years. That is, by March
1977. But most non-conforming billboards were never taken down due
to lack of funding. It was illegal to significantly repair them,
in hopes they would wear out and come down naturally, but this bill would
negate the 1972 law. There are 17,000 billboards in Wisconsin, many
non-conforming, and they often degrade natural scenery which is vital to
Wisconsin's tourism industry and quality of life. --- Co-sponsored
by 18 Republicans and 1 Democrat. Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include:
Bies, Leibham, Roessler, Breske, Seratti, McCormick and Krawczyk. STATUS:
Hearing held Oct. 9, 2003. Passed Assembly, 64 to 32, on March
2, 2004. Reported to Senate Committee on Transportation and Information
Infrastructure, and, on March 9, recommended for Senate passage.
-
Bridges Over Wild Rivers (AB530) ---
This bill would weaken existing limitations on bridges over Wild and Scenic
Rivers, with a spectific exemption for bridges for use by All Terrain Vehicles
(ATVs) and snowmobiles. This could result in severe noise and visual
impacts. on Wild and Scenic River users. Opponents of this bill point
out that Wild and Scenic Rivers are rare in this state, equal to only a
small percentage of all stream miles. Many outdoor enthusiasts
seek out Wild and Scenic Rivers precisely because they want a quiet, peaceful
natural experience. --- Introduced by Joint Committee
for Review of Administrative Rules, which has 10 members (6 Republicans
and 4 Democrats). Northeast Wisconsin members of JCRAR are: Leibham,
Grothman, Welch, and Seratti. STATUS:
A substitute amendment was passed to allow three existing ATV bridges over
the Pike, Pine, and Popple Rivers to remain. It also requires state
agencies to permit all-terrain vehicles and snowmobiles to travel in a
corridor across state land that separates an all-terrain vehicle trail
or a snowmobile trail from designated bridges or river crossings.
Passed the Assembly unanimously on Nov 5, 2003. Senate passed,
23 to 9, on March 11. Waiting for Governor's signature or veto.
Solid Waste
Reduced Paper Recycling (AB187)---
Under current law, the publisher of a newspaper is generally required to
pay a newspaper recycling fee based on the volume of newsprint used by
the publisher unless the newsprint on which the newspaper is printed contains
a specified minimum percentage of fiber derived from post-consumer waste
paper. (This is paper which has actually been sold in the marketplace,
used by consumers, and later collected for recycling. This does not
include recycling of pre-consumer paper trimmings from within paper mills.)
For 1998 to 2000, the specified percentage is 37%. For 2003 and thereafter,
the specified minimum percentage is 40%. This bill would reduce the
minimum percentage of waste fibers in newsprint to 33%, with no future
increases. --- Co-sponsored by 28 Republicans and 1 Democrat.
Northeast Wisconsin sponsors include: Van Roy, Ott, Bies, Grothman, Olsen,
McCormick, Seratti, and Welch. STATUS:
Passed both houses, signed by Governor on Dec. 11, 2003. Now, it's
called Wisconsin Act 106. Senators
voting in favor: BRESKE, BROWN, COWLES,
DARLING, ELLIS, FITZGERALD, HARSDORF, KANAVAS, KEDZIE, LASEE,
LAZICH, LEIBHAM, PANZER, PLALE, REYNOLDS, ROESSLER, SCHULTZ,
STEPP, WELCH, ZIEN, HANSEN, JAUCH, LASSA, MEYER, ROBSON,
WIRCH. Assembly members voting in favor:AINSWORTH,
ALBERS, BIES, FITZGERALD, FOTI, FREESE, FRISKE, GIELOW, GOTTLIEB,
GRONEMUS, GROTHMAN, GUNDERSON, GUNDRUM, HAHN, HINES, HONADEL, HUEBSCH,
HUNDERTMARK,
JENSEN, JESKEWITZ, JOHNSRUD,
KAUFERT, KERKMAN, KESTELL, KRAWCZYK,
KREIBICH, LADWIG, LASEE (didn't vote), LEHMAN, M., LEMAHIEU, LOEFFELHOLZ,
LOTHIAN, MCCORMICK, MEYER, MONTGOMERY, MUSSER, NASS, NISCHKE,
OLSEN, OTT, OWENS, PETROWSKI, PETTIS, POWERS, RHOADES, SERATTI,
STEINBRINK, STONE, SUDER, TOWNS, TOWNSEND,
UNDERHEIM, VAN
AKKEREN, VAN ROY, VRAKAS, VUKMIR, WARD, WEBER,
WIECKERT,
WILLIAMS, M., WOOD, J., WOOD, W., ZIEGELBAUER, SPEAKER, BALOW, COLON,
HEBL, KRUSICK, SINICKI, STASKUNAS, COGGS, HUBLER, KREUSER, LEHMAN,
J., MORRIS, SHERMAN, SHILLING, TAYLOR, TURNER, ZIEGELBAUER.
Further Information
-
Environmental Economics --- Learn how backward
these proposals really are. Environmental regulations help support
our longterm economy.
-
Proposed Legislative Bills --- Read the exact
language and history of the legislative proposals (listed by bill number).
(Background legislative information provided by Kerry
Schumann, of the Wisconsin Power Conservation Project.)
back to top
|